As you probably deduced from the picture above, I’m in Chicago for Bank Director’s annual Chairman & CEO Peer Exchange. While the conversations between peers took place behind closed doors, we teed things up with various presentations. An early one — focused on FinTech — inspired today’s post and this specific question: as a bank executive, what do you get when you add these three variables:
Stricter capital requirements (which reduces a bank’s ability to lend) + Increased scrutiny around “high-risk” lending (decreasing the amount of bank financing available) + Increases in consumer product pricing (say goodbye to price-sensitive customers)
The unfortunate answer?
Opportunity; albeit, for non-bank financial services companies to underprice banks and take significant business from traditional players. Nowhere is this more clear then in the lending space. Through alternative financial service providers, borrowers are able to access credit at lower borrowing costs. So who are banks competing with right now? Here is but a short list:
- FastPay, who provides specialized credit lines to digital businesses as an advance on receivables.
- Kabbage, a company primarily engaged in providing short-term working capital and merchant cash advance.
- OnDeck, in business to provide inventory financing, medium-term business loans.
- Realty Mogul, a peer-to-peer real estate marketplace for accredited investors to invest in pre-vetted investment properties.
- BetterFinance, which provides short-term loans for consumers to pay monthly bills and purchase smartphones.
- Lenddo, an online platform that utilizes a borrower’s social network to determine credit-worthiness.
- Lendup, a short-term online lender that seeks to help consumers establish credit and avoid the cycle of debt.
- Prosper, an online marketplace for borrowers to create and list loans, with retail and institutional investors funding the loans.
- SoFi, an online network helping recent graduates refinance student loans through alumni network.
As unregulated competition heats up, bank CEOs and Chairmen continue to seek ways to not just stay relevant but to stand out. Unfortunately, the math isn’t always in their favor, especially when alternative lenders enjoy operating costs far below banks and are not subject to the same reserve requirements as an institution. As we were reminded, consumers and small businesses don’t really care where they borrow money from, as as long as they can borrow the money they want.
Thanks to Halle Benett, Managing Director, Head of Diversified Financials Investment Banking, Keefe, Bruyette & Woods, A Stifel Company for inspiring this post. He joined us yesterday morning at the Four Seasons Chicago and laid out the fundamental shifts in banking that have opened the door for these new competitors. I thought the math he shared with the audience was elegant both in its simplicity — and profound in its potential results. Let me know what you think with a comment below or message via Twitter (@aldominick).
One Reply to “How the Math Works for Non-Financial Service Companies”